Sunday, January 31, 2021

Equity

COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated systemic inequities rooted in ageism, ableism, classism, racism, sexism, etc.  Shutdowns, physical distancing and wearing earplugs have allowed time, space and relative quiet to reflect on advocating for something better than normal (status quo).

According to San Francisco Department of Public Health (SF DPH) COVID-19 data tracker to date: 31,111 positive cases and 324 deaths (60.8% male; 61% age 80+, 16% age 70-79, 12% age 60-69, or 89% of deaths age 60+; 36.7% Asian, 20.1% Latinx, 28.4% White, 8.3% Black; 0.6% homeless).  Total COVID-19 deaths: 442,951 in U.S., over 2.18 million worldwide.

SF appears to have peaked at 373 new COVID-19 cases on Jan. 8.  After surges from holidays and ongoing attempts to recall Governor, California lifted stay-at-home orders so SF will return to limited re-openings…until the next surge, especially with more contagious coronavirus variants spreading?! 

Looks like SF DPH Director Grant Colfax is modeling layered masks for extra protection on Jan. 25?  This is first press conference where he did not remove his mask! SF DPH’s latest Stay Safer at Home order (Jan. 27) is 99 pages…for bedtime reading! 

Early in COVID pandemic, SF DPH prioritized “equity” to protect more vulnerable groups based on age (older), race (Latinx, Black), socio-economic (unhoused, living in crowded housing, without health insurance coverage), etc. Given these diverse interests, the pandemic response has been fraught with mixed messages and shifting priorities.

To its credit, SF DPH shifted to coordinate outreach with trusted members of these impacted communities, COVID-19 testing free at City sites (though when supply ran low, insured people told to get tested through private providers so City sites could serve uninsured), vaccine notification sign-up via text/email for people with smartphone/internet access, and now creating vaccination sites to serve anyone eligible to receive free vaccines.  Most sites are set-up to meet people where they are, including near public transit stops and allowing walk-ups and drive-through at high-volume sites.

In SF, gender gap in COVID-19 cases appears to be narrowing, though men still die at a higher rate that could be related to their higher prevalence of autoantibodies, high-risk behaviors, occupational exposure, etc. 

On Jan. 6 noon launch of California’s Master Plan for Aging (MPA), California Health & Human Services Secretary Mark Ghaly (pediatrician) lauded older adults as “heroes” for their “leadership” and “sacrifices”—stay at home, save lives—during COVID-19 pandemic.  

Gag the “hero” narrative; even health care workers reject “hero” label, as martyrdom against their will, sacrificed by failures to supply PPE.  Older adults under lockdown in residential long-term care (LTC) facilities (like prisoners) were stripped of their self-determination, while non-institutionalized SF residents of all ages were “followers” (not leaders) of SF’s Stay Safer at Home order and extensive lockdowns that limited movement outside home to “essential activities.” 

What are shut-ins doing at home? Before pandemic, older adults age 65+ watched TV for average of 4.5 hours per day; during pandemic, TV watching surged 8 hours a week per household and 35% increase in streaming video consumption. 

Fernando Gil-Torres, UCLA Director for Center of Policy Research on Aging, presented on California’s changing demographics: living longer at 81.9 years, California has 2nd highest average life expectancy in the nation (after Hawaii)! And California’s older population is becoming more racially/ethnically diverse; within 10 years, non-Hispanic whites will no longer represent the majority of older adults. 

Jennie Chin-Hansen, former CEO of On Lok and American Geriatrics Society, introduced California MPA’s 5 Bold Goals, with equity “baked in” each, for 2030: 

#1 Housing for All Ages and Stages: live where we choose as we age in communities that are age-, disability-, and dementia-friendly and climate- and disaster-ready.  Target: Millions of New Housing Options to Age Well

#2 Health Reimagined: access to services we need to live at home in our communities and to optimize our health and quality of life.  Target: Close the Equity Gap in and Increase Life Expectancy

#3 Inclusion and Equity, Not Isolation:  lifelong opportunities for work, volunteering, engagement, and leadership; protection from isolation, discrimination, abuse, neglect, and exploitation.  Target: Keep Increasing Life Satisfaction as We Age

#4 Caregiving That Works:  prepare for and support through rewards and challenges of caring for aging loved ones.  Target: One Million High-Quality Caregiving Jobs

#5 Affording Aging: economic security for as long as we live.  Target: Close the Equity Gap in and Increase Elder Economic Sufficiency

A week after MPA (45-page report) launch, California Department of Aging (CDA) Director Kim McCoy Wade went deeper into 10-year blueprint to promote Equity in Aging: California for All Ages by 2030! Yes, equity includes intergenerational component, explicitly calling for age-integrated community centers and volunteer engagement! MPA reports that California has more multigenerational households than any other state, due to housing costs and other financial constraints, care needs, and cultural preferences. (Yet, it doesn’t call for de-ghettoization of age segregation in housing.) 

MPA is framed around 5 goals (23 strategies, 100+ action-ready initiatives), Local Playbook, and Data Dashboard to track progress in implementing MPA for accountability.  State’s ten cabinet agencies in partnership with federal government, private sector, community groups and all stakeholders will launch 100+ initiatives within the first two years (2021-2022)!

Why on earth did CDA illustrate MPA Goal 1: Housing for All Ages & Stages with steps leading to front door entrances of houses and overgrown foliage on sidewalk? How age- and disability-friendly is this design for people who use wheelchairs or walkers, and/or depend on door-to-door paratransit? Possibly disaster-ready for earthquakes if wood-frame houses can lean on each other for support? Focus on aging in place, not constructing more segregated age 55+ communities. 

Two days after launch of MPA, Governor’s proposed budget included $250 million toward buying or rehabilitating assisted living facilities for low-income seniors. 

COVID-19 is upending MPA Goal 2: Health Reimagined by closing equity gap and increasing life expectancy. Due to COVID-19 pandemic deaths last year, life expectancy at birth for Americans will shorten by 1.13 years to 77.48 years—the largest single-year decline in life expectancy in at least 40 years and is the lowest life expectancy estimated since 2003.  Researchers from University of Southern California and Princeton estimated life expectancy declines for Black and Latinx that are 3-4 times that for Whites, widening racial disparities in life expectancy.

·       Whites 77.84 (decline by 0.68 years)

·       Blacks 72.78 (decline by 2.10 years)

·       Latinx 78.77 (decline by 3.05 years)

Asians, with life expectancy of 86.67 years, not included in research. 

“Of all the forms of inequality, injustice in health care is the most shocking and inhumane.”—Martin Luther King, Jr. speech to Medical Committee for Human Rights (Mar. 25, 1966)

California’s older adults age 65+ make up 10% of state’s population, and 75% of COVID-19 deaths during pandemic.  MPA reported only 2% of California’s population live in nursing homes, but accounted for a third of COVID-19 deaths. COVID-19 death toll is inhumane, and the underreporting of deaths a grave injustice to lives lost (particularly in New York, where its Governor ordered nursing homes to admit recovering COVID-19 patients while granting immunity to providers, and his subsequent cover-up in undercounting nursing home deaths by as much as 50%)! 

 

One reason for life expectancy gap is scientific racism and medical apartheid, according to Donald Moore, MD, MPH, of Physicians for a National Health Program-NY Metro, in a virtual forum on systemic racism in medicine, Unequal Treatment: The Unjust Death of Dr. Susan Moore.  He moderated a panel calling for greater representation of Blacks in medical field, against closure of Black medical schools while other medical schools didn’t admit Blacks, for affirmative action (though Blacks have not benefited as much as women), against Kaiser Permanente Medical School (Pasadena) firing Black Dr. Aysha Khoury after she taught a class on racial health disparities last summer, etc.  The curriculum in medical schools racialize disease, presuming Blacks have higher threshold for pain, training bias in future physicians “to minimize the pain, forgo the consent, blame the behaviors and dismiss the concerns of patients of color.” 

In a video recorded from her hospital bed before she died of COVID-19 last month, 52-year-old Black internist Dr. Susan Moore described racist treatment by white physician who dismissed her complaints of pain and requests for medication at Indiana University Health. Camara Phyllis Jones, MD, MPH, PhD, family physician and epidemiologist, led conversation about dismantling systemic racism rooted in health care, asking: “Why is it that we as Black, Hispanic, Latino, Indigenous and marginalized people have to keep showing proof of our pain and oppression? The answer is not just racism. It is racism denial.”  

The panelists discussed the importance of demanding institutional accountability in order to create substantial change, and reflected on how a publicly-financed single-payer system is a critical step in eradicating the racism that underpins inequities in our current health care system. This would be similar to how Medicare forced desegregation of hospitals by threatening to withhold federal funding from hospitals that practiced racial discrimination. (Dr. Susan Moore’s GoFundMe page set-up as she was sole provider to her surviving teenage son and her parents who both have dementia.) 

Many rich intergenerational discussions to advance MPA Goal 3: Inclusion & Equity, Not Isolation: LGBT culture, age-friendly workplace, anti-racism, feminism, financial elder abuse prosecutions, and digital equity.

As part of CDA’s Ensuring Equity in Aging webinar series, this month focused on The Culture of LGBT Older Adults.

Jenny Pardini, Community Education Advocate at Legal Assistance for Seniors (Oakland), discussed why LGBT and other marginalized older adults are vulnerable, and what providers can do to ensure equity.

Jenny discussed importance of California AB 959, LGBT Disparities Reduction Act, on collecting data on SOGI (sexual orientation, gender identity) and more: if person identifies as transgender/non-binary, ask follow-up questions regarding preferred pronoun and preferred name; Queer is generally not preferred term for LGBT people who came of age prior to mid-1970s. (California SB 932 mandates reporting SOGI for COVID-19 deaths.)  Without asking for SOGI, LGBT community risks being invisible/forgotten/erased.

When I inquire about SOGI, my cisgender older clients appear confused and often respond, “I’m normal!” (probing further, they mean heterosexual); some transgender clients identify as transgender male/female and associated pronouns, but do not want “transgender” documented in their charts; rare for older client to identify as gender non-binary (they/them). 

Jenny added that Section 1557 of Affordable Care Act prohibits discrimination on basis of gender identity (Medicare has specific code, condition 45, that tells system that services are appropriate for particular person’s body parts; since May 2014, Medicare may cover gender reassignment surgery based on medical necessity). 

Karen Anderson of Lavender Seniors of East Bay provided LGBTQ History (today’s seniors grew up in a time when their SOGI was considered a mental/religious aberration; survived by being “closeted” and “passing” as heterosexual; experienced mental health/substance abuse issues from discrimination and self-imposed isolation, etc.) and how many older LGBTQ seniors still feel at risk from lifelong experiences of marginalization (increasing vulnerability with age, many avoid supportive services in desire to remain closeted, distrusting of institutions they may need in later life, more likely to be living alone without traditional family supports and planning for LTC needs, continuing discrimination in housing/LTC facilities, not having access to retirement benefits associated with marriage—though in 2017, Social Security Administration reopened decisions that denied spousal/survivor benefits to same-sex partners based on discriminatory marriage ban).  

Karyn Skultety, Executive Director of Openhouse since 2017, presented on policy/advocacy: Because marginalized populations “age” faster due to trauma and poor access to social determinants of health due to discrimination, she recommended reconsidering age limits (65+) on senior care.  For example, a senior designated Low Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) community may provide for lower minimum age of 55 or 62. 

Openhouse was founded in 1998 by psychologist Marcy Adelman and her late partner Jeanette Gurevitch (1948-2002; SFSU MSW alum), to build SF’s first LGBT+ welcoming senior (age 55+) affordable housing, with onsite support services: 40 units at 55 Laguna (also home to Bob Ross LGBT Senior Center) in 2017, with 68% residents identifying as LGBTQ; and 79 units at 95 Laguna in 2019, with 55% LGBTQ. 

A week after her presentation, Karyn announced that she was stepping down as Openhouse ED, effective May 31, 2021, to prioritize family and return to her home state of Colorado.


"It ain't easy being surrounded by millennials in West Hollywood.  I had the experience a few months ago — going up the street by a group of gay white men in their thirties. I heard one of them say, 'Let grandpa go by.' So as I passed, I said, 'Stay well, my grandchildren.'  You’ve got to laugh." –Frank Galassi, age 82, on humor and vocabulary of happy aging, “Lessons on Resilience From LGBTQ Elders: Enduring hardship makes this population masters of perseverance,” Next Avenue (Jan. 6, 2021) 

Monmouth University School of Social Work, New Jersey Foundation for Aging, and Lifelong Montclair hosted Ageism, -isms, and the Workforce in the Age of COVID-19 conference.  Tim Driver, President of Age-Friendly Foundation, developed CAFÉ (Certified Age-Friendly Employer) as an employer-recognition program in 2006, using a proprietary evaluation method (12 standards listed above), to certify over 100+ employers (listed on website includes many financial, government, insurance, home care, retail, and telecommunications employers).

Charlotte Japp, CEO of CIRKEL, founded her intergenerational membership platform to connect generations for mutual personal and professional growth: Millennials like herself seek mentorship from Boomers like her parents who seek to stay relevant after being pushed out of their jobs at age 45.  Charlotte walks the talk, moving back to her parents’ home in New York twice since graduating college!   

Margaret Morganroth Gullette, author of Ending Ageism, or How Not to Shoot Old People (2017), talked about “middle ageism” starting at age 40, pandemic’s effect on job discrimination and unemployment during midlife, need for collective action to organize in a multi-generational coalition for new jobs and unionization that pulled up the middle-class.  She was introduced by Rutgers Social Work Professor Lauren Snedeker, author of Strength in Numbers: A Millennial’s View on the Value of Working with Older Adults (2016). 

In celebration of Martin Luther King, Jr. Day, Madam Walker Legacy Center and Indiana University (IU) presented A Call to Action: Then and Now, with activists Angela Davis (Silent Gen) and Alicia Garza (Millennial co-founder of #BlackLivesMatter), discussing "then" and "now" for civil rights, social justice, inclusion, and equality, to build a world more reflective of MLK, Jr.’s Dream.    

Program kicked off with pre-recorded welcome by IU President Michael McRobbie, who announced measures to improve diversity, equity and inclusion consistent with MLK, Jr. legacy; for example, IU School of Medicine (affiliated with IU hospital where Dr. Moore received alleged racist treatment before her COVID-19 death) was awarded grant to help educate medical students to better care for underserved populations. (Older adults are underserved, given shortage of geriatricians!)

Angela Davis said MLK, Jr. legacy is a call for black freedom requiring radical changes in structures of society, in opposition to white supremacists who cling to past with confederate flags, MAGA and racial capitalism; need to defund police link to slavery/mass incarceration and imagine new institutions that do not rely on violence; strategies to bring BIPOC into institutions try to diversify but do not change systems that perpetuate racism.  Examples: South Africa now has almost all-black police, but same problem of inflicting violence on POC embedded in system; not assume work is done after Black President Obama elected, but should have demonstrated against his deportations; Biden is moderate and needs to be pushed in struggle for revolution.  (Will Biden's "diversity cabinet" appointees, which exclude Asian Americans, help marginalized people or perpetuate ruling class politics?)

She talked about campaign to transform marginalized into mainstream, calling for universities to stop marginalizing ethnic and feminist studies in curriculum, and need for interdisciplinary studies.  While she never before had seen so many white participants in anti-racist protests against police brutality after George Floyd was lynched, she voiced concern how radical ideas get co-opted by status quo (capitalized by corporations) so need for more radical ideas and collective activism to engage, organize, and mobilize more people into fold demanding structural changes.  She argued that because systems of injustice and inequality faced by Black people were not created by Black people, they cannot be dismantled by Black people; instead, white people need to recognize their problem and their stake in the future of justice, equality and freedom as anyone else.

Alicia Garza said racism is about rigged rules, with lots of “nice” people who help advance racist systems, show up at Jan. 6 U.S. Capitol insurrection (“inside job”) and resort to violence if they can’t control by consent, after Black voters helped secure victory in runoffs for 1st Black and 1st Jewish senators from Georgia (Warnock and Ossoff, who each raised more than $100 million to fund their campaigns) to return Democratic control of U.S. Senate, threatening white power structure.  She called to transform how systems operate, hold government accountable, include people at the table and distribute resources in the richest country where there’s “plenty for everyone”!

Jan. 6 is a date that will live in infamy for launch of California’s first-ever MPA, which took place at noon Pacific Time while white supremacists rioted the U.S. Capitol in Washington, D.C.!  As I was absorbed attending the live MPA program, I was clueless to the insurrection occurring real-time at our nation’s capital.  Great listening to this intergenerational discussion about where to go from this current state of affairs.  In particular, can we advance more progressive policies to uplift all lives, instead of allowing authoritarian opportunists to use race and economic class anxiety that further divide people?

To make sense of the violence at our nation’s capital and what to expect next, tuned into Storming the Capitol: Trumpism’s Last Stand? with UC Berkeley Law Professors:

·       john a. powell, director of Othering & Belonging Institute and contributor to Trumpism and Its Discontents (2020), believes rioters storming the Capitol was a coup, particularly given the lack of police response, and Trump has channeled rioters’ underlying white resentment (i.e., white people’s loss of status translates to racial hostility). 

·       Ian Haney Lopez (“HaLo”), author of Merge Left: Fusing Race and Class, Winning Elections, and Saving America (2019), was not sure it was a coup; rather, he believes Trumpism (“stoking racial fear to break solidarity culture wars”) has been over 50 years in the making, in response to the success of the New Deal (government work for majority v. very rich) with a faction of Republicans working for the rich and, instead of appealing to class dynamics, promote propaganda that “civilized white folks” are under threat of being replaced by “savage POC.”  This has played out with police treating protestors for racial equality as dangerous v. hands-off white resentment/rage at Capitol.  He urged us to learn more on how to beat dog-whistle politics and build race-class solidarity at https://race-class-academy.com/: “When we come together to reject racism as a weapon of the rich, we can make sure that the government works for all of us, of every race and color.”

(HaLo’s thinking about multi-racial shared power reminds me of how multi-ethnic Asian settlors organized in plantations of Hawaii, building “local” solidarity.  HaLo, who attended Punahou and Harvard Law as contemporary of Deporter-in-Chief Obama, believes racist call-out strategy doesn’t work, and Obama lacked confidence to challenge racism but followed Clinton in new Democrat tradition of getting funding from Wall Street and ruling on their behalf, like bailing out banks during Great Recession.) 

Shorenstein Center hosted wonderful intergenerational discussion of Beyond White Feminism: Not 'Healing' US Back to an Anti-Feminist Future with Koa Beck (Mills ’09), author of White Feminism: From the Suffragettes to Influencers and Who They Leave Behind (2021); Benita Roth, Binghamton Professor and author of Separate Roads to Feminism: Black, Chicana, and White Feminist Movements in America's Second Wave (2010); and Barbara Smith, activist who co-founded Combahee River Collective (which called attention to racism in feminist movement in 1974) and Kitchen Table: Women of Color Press (with Audre Lorde in 1980). 

They discussed ways that gender policies can be re-envisioned for a more inclusive future of equity and opportunities rather than return to the old “normal” (exploitative labor, poor wages, lack of paid and/or subsidized parental leave and family care); confronting white supremacy, challenging systems of patriarchy and neoliberalism, defunding police (stop militarizing poor communities of color and mass incarceration), funding social safety net and Green New Deal, actively recruiting academics of color and women in STEM, pushing for workers’ rights in addressing care crisis, etc.

Last summer, National Organization for Women (NOW) and Planned Parenthood NY (whose founder Margaret Sanger promoted eugenics) finally woke to their own systemic racism and ousted their white feminist leaders after complaints of racism and toxic “mean girl” culture.  Aileen Fernandez, African-American who succeeded NOW founder Betty Friedan as President in 1970-71, resigned from NOW to focus on racial inequity; fifty years later, NOW has a Black President again.

“The crime of financial abuse of elders is rampant and growing. People are living longer and they become more vulnerable with age. An older, perhaps forgetful person is an easy target. Why isn’t law enforcement going after the perpetrators?”—Carolyn Rosenblatt, “Frustration For Families: Law Enforcement Isn’t Pursuing Financial Elder Abusers,” Forbes (Sept. 27, 2019) 

Paul Greenwood, retired San Diego elder abuse deputy district attorney (DA), answered this question in Dissecting Elder Financial Exploitation: When it’s Not Just a Civil Matter: sometimes determination to pursue a case as civil v. criminal is made by police, who gather evidence but typically are not qualified to interpret evidence using legal analysis, which is the job of the prosecutor. For example, apparent voluntariness is diluted by fraud, undue influence or exploiting mental limitations of older victim—as in a case that police decided was civil until DA’s investigator found evidence of fraudulent photo of suspect who photo-shopped his image into couple’s portrait, suspect claimed to be long-lost nephew and persuaded older woman to purchase property as joint tenants with his right of survivorship; suspect sent to prison! Paul emphasized importance of multi-disciplinary Financial Abuse Specialist Teams (FAST).


During the pandemic, which has hit older adults especially hard, this divide between technology “haves” and “have-nots” has serious consequences.

Older adults in the “haves” group have more access to virtual social interactions and telehealth services, and more opportunities to secure essential supplies online. Meanwhile, the “have-nots” are at greater risk of social isolation, forgoing medical care and being without food or other necessary items.—Judith Graham, “Technology Divide Between Senior ‘Haves’ and ‘Have-Nots’ Roils Pandemic Response,” Kaiser Health News (July 24, 2020) 

SF Tech Council hosted Equity through Technology conversation with Google guys on how they work with public sector organizations to find data-driven solutions around issues of access and equity. 

·       For people with tech devices and internet access, they shared Grow with Google https://grow.google/, a free online training resource intended to increase digital participation. (New Blogger makes me want to decrease my participation☹.)

·       To increase digitally accessible communication across “continuum of language,” Google provides language translation, artificial intelligence virtual agents, speech-text-speech https://speechtextspeech.appspot.com/, captioning, etc.  Google also worked with State of Hawaii on application that translates legislative content into 80 languages (but no Pidgin, like Hawaiian Pidgin Bible). https://ets.hawaii.gov/ets-collaboration-with-google-cloud-leads-to-development-of-language-translation-application/

·       Examples of using power of data for equitable service: look at communities most impacted by COVID-19 and then gauge their willingness to receive vaccine; review google search patterns to see waves of interest in varying topics (e.g., senior meals related searches in April, testing sites in early May) that can inform need to mobilize services

MPA Goal 4: Caregiving that Works has target of 1 million high-quality caregiving jobs.  This is challenging given the history of gender and racial discrimination in caregiving work, with BIPOC women providing disproportionate share.  Caregiving is also essential work that is often invisible as it takes place in institutions and private homes.  

JFCS Seniors at Home hosted Caregiver: A Love Story (2020) documentary short film screening + discussion about family caregiver experience with filmmaker Jessica Zitter, MD, MPH (who previously made Extremis film about her work with ICU patients at end-of-life).  

Dr. Zitter intended to make a film about home hospice, which she arranged for her 59-year-old friend Bambi, who decided to forgo further treatment for her terminal cancer and live out her final weeks at home.  After Bambi’s husband Rick quit his job to become unpaid primary caregiver during the last 9 weeks of Bambi’s life, Rick became ill himself and got respite when Bambi goes to a nursing home for five days. (Respite in nursing home not good option during pandemic! According to Rick, home hospice offered only 1.5 hours of personal assistance per week, and they couldn’t afford to pay for homecare.) After Bambi’s death, Rick said he had no regrets because “this is all about love.” 

While editing the filmed footage, Dr. Zitter shifted focus to Rick as 24/7 caregiver, who ends up assisting with toileting and more, though Bambi initially said she never wanted him to “wipe my butt.”  Mature, modern and realistic love story…unlike sappy Love Story (1970) that opens with “What can you say of a 25-year-old girl who dies?” (I say, call her a 25-year-old “woman”!)

JFCS Palliative Geriatric Care Manager Gwen Harris (SFSU MA Gerontology ‘06) moderated discussion with Dr. Zitter, who explained that as a palli doctor focused on patient care, she did not know about “family caregiver burden,” which she now considers a “rising public health crisis” and called for legislation to support family caregivers like Biden’s Plan.

MPA Goal 5: Affordable Aging targets closing equity gaps and increasing elder economic security.  MPA noted local model: SF’s Project Homekey (plan for SF residents in emergency housing to exit into permanent supportive housing hotels purchased by the City using state grants) and Meals Expansion during COVID-19 pandemic. 

To prevent spread of coronavirus, California housed 22,300 people (including 2,000 in SF, prioritizing seniors and adults who are medically vulnerable) under Project Roomkey.  With Project’s cost of rooms reimbursable from Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA)—only 75% under Trump, and now increased to 100%, retroactive and continuing through September 2021 under Biden…SF plans to open more hotel rooms to house homeless! Much needed, as MPA report points out that California residents age 50+ are the fastest growing population of homeless in the state, and unhoused older adults experience health problems typically seen in people 20 years older.

Recently, CDA Director was appointed to California Department of Insurance’s LTC Insurance Task Force, charged with preparing a feasibility report with recommendations by January 1, 2023 for a statewide LTC insurance program intended to address inequities in affordable LTC within health and social support systems.

COVID-19 vaccine eligibility priority groups

With limited vaccine supplies, being classified as vulnerable is desirable for people who seek vaccine prioritization.

This month’s Senior & Disability Action (SDA) meeting focused on setting this year’s advocacy priorities, with a review of last year’s successful care rationing campaign that could be used for vaccine prioritization.

1.   What is our demand? Change state care rationing guidelines – no discrimination against seniors and PWD

2.   Who is target (who can make change)? CA Governor, DPH Director

3.   Who benefits? Constituents account for equity

4.   Who’s with us? Allies

5.   Who’s against us? Opponents

Last month, CDC Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) recommended this prioritization for offering COVID-19 vaccination:

·       Phase 1a, health care personnel and LTC facility residents

·       Phase 1b, persons aged ≥75 years (given high risk of hospitalization, illness and death from COVID-19) and non–health care frontline essential workers (firefighters, police, corrections, food & agri, US Postal Service, manufacturing, public transit, teachers, daycare)

·       Phase 1c, to persons aged 65–74 years, persons aged 16–64 years with high-risk medical conditions, and essential workers not included in Phase 1b.

After Phase 1a, states left to create own prioritization plans. On Jan. 12, federal government extended eligibility from age 75+ to 65+, and to people under age 65 with pre-existing health conditions to speed up process, though vaccine supply fell short.  Next day, California opened vaccines to age 65+, but left out younger people with pre-existing conditions. 

On Jan. 19, SDA’s Care Rationing Workgroup hosted forum on COVID Vaccination Allocation with Katy Tang, SF DPH Director of Public and Governmental Affairs.  As she was new to her position (joined SF DPH last month) and substitute presenter, Katy read through her presentation and offered to follow-up “later” on questions.  After she read "CDPH Allocation Strategy" slide listing SNF but no mention of other residential LTC facilities in Phase 1a, I asked about inclusion of other residential LTC facilities like assisted living? Katy said SF based on California DPH guidelines.  If so, I noted (in Zoom chat) it would be helpful for SF DPH to be consistent with state DPH, which provided this language in Phase 1a: “Residents of skilled nursing facilities, assisted living facilities, and similar long-term care settings for older or medically vulnerable individuals.”  “Later” SF DPH revised to conform with state.

Vaccination in LTC facilities took longer due to informed consent issues from residents with cognitive impairment or locating their proxies, and some health workers declined vaccination. 

Katy read Phase 1b-Tier 1 listing age 75+ and certain at-risk of exposure essential workers in education/childcare (as there’s pressure to open up schools, and teachers’ union concerned about safety), emergency services, food and agriculture; Phase 1b-Tier 2 listed age 65+, as supplies allow. 

Then six days later…on Jan. 25, California Governor announced change to age-based eligibility system after vaccinating health care workers, LTC residents, teachers, emergency personnel, and those age 65+.  This latest change made to speed up process as much easier to verify age than seeking documentation for essential workers and high-risk medical conditions.  Needless to say, this latest change provoked outrage among people with high-risk medical conditions, which is focus of SDA’s latest advocacy campaign. 

At Jan. 21 annual meeting of Hawaii Pacific Gerontological Society (HPGS), Hawaii Lt. Gov. Josh Green (who also works as ER doc) presented on Hawaii COVID-19 update: from Mar. 7, 2020 to Jan. 16, 2021, Hawaii had 2nd lowest infection rate in U.S. (after Vermont, which is rural and smaller) and lowest COVID-19 death rate in U.S. Statewide mask wearing is 86% according to Hawaii Department of Health survey for week of Jan. 17. 

COVID-19 impacts on health, housing and unemployment were less positive: 15% increase in Medicaid beneficiaries, bringing total to 380,000 (1 in 4 statewide); doubled call volume to National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) Hawaii; 46% increase in calls to Domestic Violence Action Center helpline; 60% increase in food insecurity (1 in 5 statewide); and 11,000 households behind in rent.

As of Jan. 20, Hawaii administered 45% (70,095/154,150) of vaccines received. Vaccination distribution rolled out in phases: Phase 1a (Dec. 2020-Jan. 2021) focus on healthcare workers and LTC residents; Phase 1b (Dec. 2020-Mar. 2021) focus on Hawaii residents age 75+ (est. 109,000) and frontline essential workers on-site and close proximity to others (est. 50,000).

A week later, 500 Hawaii State Capitol lawmakers and staff received COVID-19 vaccines as frontline essential workers in Phase 1b of vaccination prioritization alongside kupuna age 75+! How dare they get vaccinated before my parents age 75+, who are scheduled for their first COVID vaccine shots tomorrow?!

Though older adults are prioritized, many faced barriers to access information about availability and scheduling vaccination appointments in overwhelmed system with website crashes (plus digital divide with only 59% of older adults have home broadband services, exacerbated in low-income communities), lacking social supports and private transportation for long distances (especially in rural areas) and/or drive-through vaccination sites, waiting in long lines without access to toilets, and prospect of repeating process for 2nd shots! 

Whites are getting vaccinated at higher rates than members of historically marginalized groups who may not live to eligibility age 75 or 65 (Black men, LGBT, unhoused, etc.), which raises issues of equitable access, particularly under California's latest age-based system. 

Equity efforts focused on COVID-19 racial/ethnic disparities. SF Human Rights Commission hosted two-part series exploring the racial history of pandemics to inform equitable access to vaccination and recovery, with representatives of impacted communities to address vaccine hesitancy and engage access (language and culture).  Part 1 Pandemic within Pandemics: The Racist History of Disease looked at the past to help understand the present and prepare for the future, because to ignore history is to repeat it.  Waves of disease (cholera, 1918 Influenza, HIV/AIDS, COVID-19) often trigger a social pandemic of hatred, racism and xenophobia, while exacting its heaviest toll on traditionally vulnerable communities. Almost one year into COVID-19 pandemic, BIPOC communities bear the brunt of the pandemic.  

The program featured community leaders starting with Indigenous Elder Mary Travis Allen, who opened with land acknowledgement, and American Indian Cultural Center Executive Director April McGill shared history and generational trauma of indigenous people decimated by infectious diseases brought by white colonists/settlors, who exacerbated mistrust by infecting blankets with smallpox. 

Valerie Tulier-Laiwa, Coordinator of Latino Task Force for COVID-19, discussed politics and epidemics (scapegoating migrants as disease-carriers); eugenics and unethical clinical trials (Puerto Rican women used as guinea pigs for Enovid birth control pills); California targeted Latinas for forced sterilization; allegations of “mass hysterectomies at ICE.”  She concluded with take-aways to engage in community with the first wave of vaccinations, empower and listen to those doubly impacted by stigma and disease.

Patsy Tito, Executive Director of Samoan Community Development Center (SCDC), shared challenges faced by Pacific Islanders who make up less than 1% of SF population, small so less visible and harder to draw attention to needs, sometimes categorized with Asians; yet, PIs have highest per capita cases of health disparities; many do not have healthcare because some undocumented or lack access to resources—took her 6 months to get COVID test; heartbreaking to be separated from family, especially elders; silence no longer an option. (Awesome to hear from Patsy, who I met years ago when she advocated SF Department of Aging & Adult Services to replace western meals with more culturally appropriate Polynesian foods for SCDC’s Senior Center to boost participation.  SCDC became model for American Samoa’s own senior congregate lunch program!) 

Ayanna Bennett, MD, SF DPH Director of Health Equity, discussed how history of medical experimentation, racial discrimination in health care systems, implicit bias in medical decision-making, etc. make it difficult for BIPOC to seek out and receive appropriate care.  She asked that we reframe vaccine hesitancy as an assumption of logical choice based on awareness of history (e.g., 1932-1972 Tuskegee syphilis deception using Blacks for data collection v. treatment; segregated care/denial of treatment access for Blacks during 1918 flu pandemic and polio epidemic until 1950s vaccine; 1981 HIV disproportionate impact on Blacks until 20 years later dedicated federal program specific to Blacks). Dr. Bennett advised to challenge system by asking these questions to prove whether trustworthy: Equal information? Equal risk? Equal access? Equal options?

Part 2: Understanding Community Response to Vaccines: An Anti-Racist Approach featured Michael Liao, NICOS Chinese Health Coalition Programs Director, presented on Building Trust with Chinese Community, discussing importance of: 

·       understanding client’s language, dialect, and literacy levels; non-verbal language/communication, such as saving face & deference to authority; differences in communication patterns (eye contact, emotional expression) 

·       Recommendations: don’t assume smiles & nods mean client agrees/understands you; ensure comprehension, ask clients to repeat info back to you; exhibit empathy by mirroring gesture & tone

·       understanding client’s socio-political experience that may have clinical implications, pre- & post-migration (e.g., persecution by one’s own government back home), and discrimination/exploitation (e.g., being targeted by scammers disguised as authority figures)

When Michael discussed working with the family, not just the individual, I thought this is actually very common when working with older adults – either by client consent or family member is power of attorney/proxy.  Also important to consider client’s level of assimilation/acculturation by asking about client’s expectations.

Michael shared organizational strategies, such as ensuring that service providers look like those they are serving, speak like them and are sensitive to their needs; diverse representation in agency workforce at all levels; bilingual and staff of color are supported; training on cultural humility and competency. (NICOS provided resource list of language interpretation and translation services.) 

Dr. Bennett said SF vaccine rollout's chief obstacle is not enough doses, while SF DPH continues to partner with hospital systems to quickly and efficiently get people vaccinated; ensure those most impacted by virus have access to vaccine; commit to ensuring transparent and easy process; follow 3-pronged distribution strategy to high-volume vaccination sites, community-based distribution (mobile, hubs, clinics), and pharmacies.

Safety net

Government budget deficits are unraveling the old-age safety net, leaving seniors on waitlist for in-home aides and home-delivered meals. 

Gray Panthers hosted Zoom meeting to discuss SF budget crisis and its impact on services to seniors and adults with disabilities.  Due to loss of revenues and continued uncertainties about recovery from COVID-19 pandemic, SF Mayor requested that all City departments reduce General Fund budgets by 7.5% in each of the next two fiscal years; priorities to support City’s economic recovery, COVID response, homelessness services, and initiatives that advance racial equity.  

Marie Jobling, Executive Director of Community Living Campaign and Co-Chair of SF Dignity Fund Coalition, explained due to hard economic times, Dignity Fund will not receive annual allocation of $3 million for next two years.  Marie noted housing continues to be the biggest driver of living costs for SF residents, who require $4K per month to live alone, according to Elder Economic Security Index; she leaves housing advocacy to SDA.  Her advocacy focus will be on changing Medi-Cal asset limits (currently $2K for single, $3K for couple, unchanged since 1989). 

Shireen McSpadden, Executive Director of SF Department of Disability and Aging Services (DAS), explained that federal CARES Act funds offset some local funding in Elder Justice and food assistance.  IHSS 7% cut in hours have been restored; hourly wage increases, which were suspended due to economic downturn, will be implemented to $17.50 on Feb. 1, 2021, $18 on July 1, 2021, and $18.75 on July 1, 2022.  She concluded with need to remain vigilant—e.g., state’s early COVID crisis guidelines discriminated against older age until advocates fought back—because it’s “hard to get people to care about older adults and people with disabilities.”

Gray Panthers support a wealth tax on American billionaires who benefited from tax cuts and deregulation under Trump. 

Kevin Prindiville, JD, Executive Director of Justice in Aging (JIA), delivered keynote at Senior Services Coalition (SSC) of Alameda County’s Making the Difference Together: Taking Stock of the Aging Policy Landscape in 2021 conference via Zoom. 

Kevin said coming up in March, JIA will announce its new strategic initiative to advance equity in aging, ensuring all its programs—trainings, policies, class action litigation—are centered in equity, in particular racial equity. He described JIA’s internal work for the past five years to build a more inclusive and equitable culture, starting with a need for more diverse staff, and bringing in consultants to build a more inclusive culture to enable everyone to do their best work.  He acknowledged this internal work involved willingness to be uncomfortable and vulnerable around identity, confronting one’s own privilege (fragility?), but trust in the intent with the idea of moving forward and growing, as diversity enabled more considerations to inform decision-making and more power to connect with more diverse partners with lived experiences to find better policy solutions.  In this process, they were in a better position to understand the “massive inequities that face people as they age” and the cumulative impact of systemic structural inequities like racism, sexism, homophobia, ableism, nativism, etc. as people grow older that lead to huge disparities in poverty, economic security and access to health care. These disparities are more pronounced based on race, among BIPOC. 

Kevin noted that JIA has been focused on fighting poverty for almost 50 years, but realized “fighting poverty is not the same as advancing equity.”  At the same time, he says they “get pushback from the aging community about talking about (racial) equity too much” and resistance from other communities who don’t see age as an equity consideration when California decided to prioritize vaccination for people 65+, instead of equity considerations for essential workers, younger people with chronic health conditions, etc.

To address the diversity in pipeline issue, given the lower numbers of BIPOC law school graduates, Kevin decided that their hire for newly created Director of Equity & Racial Justice Advocacy would not need to be a lawyer. 

(Pandemic has accelerated equity by doing away with standardized testing in many college admissions; historically merit-based selective Lowell High School in SF will be under lottery system for upcoming academic year, and possibly indefinitely to diversify student body.)

After Kevin’s keynote, my next favorite part of this conference was listening to advocates describe Prizes to Keep Our Eyes On: Wendy Peterson, Director of SSC, wanted to expand Adult Protective Services’ Home Safe (homeless assistance and prevention) program beyond sunset date of June 2021, and promote digital inclusion for seniors and low-income communities by expanding broadband connectivity to affordable/subsidized housing. 

My prize idea: More organic cotton shirts, union printed with image of Bernie’s sensible chic to raise $ for aging services, like nearly $2 million within five days for Meals on Wheels and other charities! 

SF public school teacher called out Bernie’s fashion at inauguration as white privilege, but didn’t call out Janet Yellen who was dressed similarly.  Seems more like old people privilege in operation as 79-year-old Bernie and 74-year-old Janet were dressed appropriately in waterproof parkas in windy and snow flurry day because older people can lose body heat fast. 

“Bernie wore something that is accessible to normal people. People can't afford those lovely outfits that everybody else wore, although they were nice to look at. It was nice to have a little piece of reality, you know, and of normal people in such a prominent event.”—Jen Ellis, “Meet Jen Ellis, The Woman Behind Bernie Sanders' Inauguration Day Mittens,” NPR (Jan. 21, 2021) 

https://www.fa-mag.com/news/how-stocks-did-under-president-trump-59887.html

I confess: When I hear “equity,” I think ownership interest in an asset such as equity security (stock), or investment of financial capital.  After all, much of my career was focused on equity investing in retirement portfolios, and the language is similar (plus good stuff for working stiffs to know!): the value of equity in asset allocation based on time horizon and risk tolerance, with diversification across different asset classes, companies, industries, and geographies.  As people get closer to accessing retirement funds, increasing exposure to bonds/cash helps to buffer decline in more volatile equity (risk-reward).  This was mostly color-blind, except for “green” investing. Similar to affirmative action, tax laws governing qualified retirement plans enable a form of wealth distribution: during annual compliance testing, a tax-qualified plan that is deemed to disproportionately benefit/discriminate in favor of key employees (company owners/officers)/highly compensated employees requires the plan sponsor (employer) to make contributions to non-key/non-highly compensated employees. Outside of qualified plans, investment in equities has cumulative advantage of long-term capital gains taxed at rates lower than ordinary income.

Now equity is so racialized in USA, and this racial reckoning is long overdue.  Yet equity is multi-dimensional, identities are intersectional, and these considerations are more important as older adults become more heterogeneous with age.    

Older Americans Act, which provides federal funding of home and community-based programs for older adults, uses equity standards in targeting older adults with the greatest economic or social need and those who are at risk for institutional placement.  Older Californians Act specifies low-income, non-English speaking, minority, and frail persons.  SF DAS priority populations are persons who are socially isolated, with low-income, with limited English-speaking proficiency, from communities of color, who identify as LGBTQ, and at risk of institutionalization...so we can live equitably after all!


Wow! During walk in my neighborhood, spotted these abandoned gerontology books... hope someone picks up on them! I've kept my gero books for reference because aging is our present and future!

Saturday, October 31, 2020

Rise

Herb Alpert’s Rise (1979 instrumental) has been playing like an earworm ever since I attended this month’s virtual screening of his documentary, thanks to AARP Movies for Grown-Ups. (While I had reservations about joining an organization that sells insurance and opposes single-payer healthcare, decided to invest in “risk-free” aka cancel anytime AARP membership for access to publications and events; no age requirement unless one wants to purchase age-restricted insurance products.)  

“Herb Alpert Is…” feel-good film this year, like his melancholy yet uplifting music! So mesmerizing, check out his Smile and Wonderful World.  With mandatory mask wearing in public due to COVID-19 pandemic, it will be some time before we can hear live wind instruments like trumpet playing so recordings are good for now.

Herb’s now 85 years old, nearly didn’t recognize him with his beard.  Walking past his elementary school in Los Angeles, Herb shared that a teacher couldn’t decide whether to give him an A or B grade for reading, so she brought in another teacher for him to read, and the teacher told him he was a “B reader, at best.”  From that point on, Herb said, he became an introvert.  Fortunately, his school also offered music appreciation, and Herb chose the trumpet, which “spoke” for him.  When neighbors complained about his trumpet playing, his mother encouraged him to play louder (not considerate!).  Despite mean teachers, industry v. inferiority resolved in favor of competence for Herb.

“Herb Alpert Is…” a beautiful life review, with Herb’s resolution of Erikson’s stages of psychosocial development to achieve virtues beyond competence: fidelity, love, care and wisdom.  Like jazz, this documentary is non-linear, improv-like, meandering with moments of Herb’s reflective self-awareness, vulnerability and earnest striving for authenticity: playing trumpet in the Army, where he perceived other trumpeters playing “better” so he determined to find his “own” voice, inspired to capture sounds of Tijuana Brass after attending a bullfight while on vacation (identity v. confusion, though critics today might accuse him of cultural appropriation?); ignoring Sonny Bono’s advice to “get out of the business” (industry v. inferiority revisited); being rich and famous, but miserable in Beverly Hills (he becomes silent in this exploration, so respect his privacy; as an introvert, I view famous=miserable), ending his marriage then getting remarried and moving to Malibu (intimacy v. isolation); getting “stuck” and unable to play until a teacher in NY helps him re-establish playing his trumpet, knowing how to compensate for not speaking much by partnering with spokesperson in business, trusting his intuition in signing some of my favorite singer-songwriters (Carole King, Cat Stevens, Peter Frampton, Sting/The Police, etc.) to A&M Records, which he co-founded so artists would be treated better (generativity v. stagnation).

As an older adult, Herb pays it forward by generously giving to music appreciation/arts education (notably Music Mends Minds intergenerational support group to address cognitive issues in older adults), waking up each purposeful day to “listen to your soul” with creative expression in daily (almost spiritual) practice playing his trumpet or piano, painting and sculpting for a remarkable legacy (integrity v. despair) and sharing his life process (wisdom).  Arts=liberation, much needed in K-12 and beyond!

For at least his first half century, clean-cut Herb appeared almost like Certified Young Person Paul Rudd, and documentary wasn’t too keen presenting chronology other than wife #1 came before wife #2; each wife appeared in videos of his #1 hits: This Guy’s in Love with You (1968, rare use of his vocals! wife #1 appeared quite hilarious in heavy mascara) and Rise (co-written by his nephew Randy, notable for spouting only F-bomb in film). Documentary is just under two hours, and I wanted more time with Herb, who is easy on ears and eyes, and maybe ask what did he think about Rise being used in rape scene in General Hospital soap opera? Herb Alpert is such an endearing blast to the past, as my boomer uncle played his vinyl records; and I liked listening to Rise on the radio (though Andy Gibb was my heartthrob in 1979 during a time when Video Killed the Radio Star). 

Herb defined himself primarily as an introvert and artist, which is so refreshing in these politically correct times that would expect him to identify as son of Eastern European Jewish immigrants.  As a MSW student required to take a diversity course, I was annoyed that an assignment required me to write about privilege and oppression based on identities of age, gender, sexual orientation, class, religion, mental and physical abilities, nationality, race/ethnicity,…but I could not select introversion that has defined my existence in a society that privileges extroversion?! 

As an introvert who values autonomy and solitude, I initially welcomed distancing and working remotely from home during COVID-19 pandemic...until my extroverted neighbors also were stuck at home blasting their music (not Herb Alpert) and interrupting my Zoom meetings.  With bars shutdown during stay home order, it’s like how Prohibition drove imbibing behaviors underground, as neighbors seemed to make their homes into bars with noisy guests carrying 6-packs and filling up recyclables bin with emptied cans/bottles of alcohol.

Pre-pandemic SF was crowded so welcomed news of recent exodus from SF, with whopping 96% year-on-year rise in housing inventory, thanks to remote work...but could this mean leaving behind mostly retired old people and people receiving government subsidies for basic needs (housing, SNAP, Medi-Cal, SSI, etc.) who contribute less tax? Society needs taxes to provide public services for the common good, and make government leaders accountable to resident taxpayers!

Anyway, my own school experience was like Pink Floyd’s Another Brick in the Wall (1979) with thought control and dark sarcasm in the classroom.  Elementary school was my introduction to losing autonomy and forced assimilation into the ways of an institution – something alien to my free-range childhood at home (and I was spared daycare/preschool).  I hated age-segregation (as my tabula rasa peers simply were not as interesting as my parents/grandparents), imposed afternoon naps in kindergarten, authoritarian school bell ringing, rote memorizing, series of holiday celebrations (which shaped my preference for truth-seeking like de-colonizing Thanksgiving), etc.  I also became an introvert and autodidact, preferring the sound of silence found in the library where I could quietly explore my curiosity.  

“You tell me it's the institution

Well, you know you better free your mind instead”

--John Lennon & Paul McCartney, Revolution (1968)


Those formative years shaped my resistance to this day, always seeking home and community-based services (HCBS) options over institutions that impose hierarchical and regimented structures (mass control), squelching self-determination, creativity and uniqueness. Growing up in a tight-knit family and faith community, members took care of each other, so I never gave thought to institutional care.  When I began my career in investment management and personal trust administration serving high net worth clients (“banking very few, very well”), money bought everything needed to support aging in place. 

(As an intense 20-something-year-old, I yearned for a more challenging career than simply throwing money to solve problems, so switched to institutional trust focused on qualified retirement plans to benefit rank-and-file employees.  My encore career as gerontologist has been the most challenging, largely due to confronting ageism at all levels—individual, institutional, structural/systemic—and its harmful impacts on quality of life.) 

No elementary school library would be complete without libertarian socialist Nathan J. Robinson’s charming antifascist children’s book, Don’t Let the Pigeon Question the Rules: A Parody for Tyrannical Youngsters (2014), which promotes the law of conscience and critical thinking of alternatives (why it’s preferable to “befriend” v. “get” a puppy) than unquestioning obedience in servitude to officious authoritarian/totalitarian mortals.  Likewise, consider a return to New Deal economist John Maynard Keynes, who fought authoritarianism with economic policies to live the good life 😊, because the value of human life does not depend on economic productivity.   

“The moral obligation that we all have is to help sustain the life around us, and we hope that others will sustain us too when we are “feeble” and in need.

…In the United States, work is the point of life, rather than life being the point of work. In many European countries, leisure is taken very seriously indeed, and the purpose of working is so that we may have more of it (leisure)… Life is beautiful in and of itself, and I do not need the old folks to produce scholarly papers in order to care about keeping them alive.”—UK-born Nathan J. Robinson, “Animals Are Pointless, And We Should Be Too,” Current Affairs (Jan/Feb 2020) 

Long-term care (LTC)

As an introvert, I tend to approach work like a cultural anthropologist doing non/participant-observation.  I have worked in institutional LTC settings like adult day health care (ADHC), assisted living facility (ALF) and nursing homes (non-profit, public), so I regard them as hierarchical workplaces.  These LTC facilities operated on the assumption that imposing “structure” (routines) on the lives of retired older adults was somehow beneficial—yet more likely to benefit budgets and staff work schedules.  Thus, I also associate LTC facilities with the gnawing disaffection of my oppressive K-12 years that I would not want to repeat (try watching Groundhog Day every day).  Group travel tours are similar (“you’re on tour, not vacation!”) but manageable because they’re short-term.

While ADHC and nursing homes operate under the medical model (qualifying for Medicaid/Medicare funding) and infection control training was part of orientation, ALF are non-medical (private pay) and could benefit from training.  Medical or not, congregate LTC facilities all operate under economies of scale, mass production with little personalization, though some ALF try to market as luxury lodgings with nickel and dime fees for services. 

In my experience, ALF residents seemed to cope with institutional life (and their medical ailments) through alcohol consumption, cannabis (actually knew two residents who got wealthy from cannabis production enterprises!), and considering California’s End of Life Option Act (EOLOA).  Self-education important because California EOLOA contains conscience clause so health care provider has no liability for “refusing to inform a patient regarding his or her rights…and not referring an individual to a physician who participates” (see Deciding with dignity: The terminally ill patient's right to information about California EOLOA and Dale-Jablonowski v. University of California Board of Regents case dismissed). 

None of these coping mechanisms were available to residents at nursing homes that received federal funds because cannabis (Schedule 1 substance) and medical aid in dying remain illegal under federal law; alcohol abuse was non-existent due to interventions from interdisciplinary team concerned over interactions with drugs or fall risk.

At ADHC under Community Based Adult Services before COVID-19 pandemic, participants were required to stay on-site for at least 4 hours each day for reimbursement ($76 from Medi-Cal Managed Care, $90 from Veterans Affairs).  But this attendance requirement was never enforced and even I turned a blind-eye because participants were mostly showing up for specific services: health care (physical therapy exercises, monitoring of vitals, medication management, etc.), social services (as-needed care coordination, case management, counseling, etc.), and hot lunch (depending on menu).  Participants who stayed 4 hours mostly had cognitive impairment and seemed indifferent to activities with blasting music (holiday celebrations, coloring, puzzles, etc. reminiscent of kindergarten), and they did not leave early because ADHC was respite for their family caregivers.  One silver lining of COVID-19 pandemic has been allowing ADHC “without walls,” accelerating flexibility of reimbursement for services delivered in private homes…closer to On Lok’s Program of All-Inclusive Care for the Elderly (PACE) model that combines HCBS.


On Lok changed its tagline from “Experience matters in senior care” to “Where seniors embrace life.”  Though a partner to SF Reframing Aging campaign, On Lok ignored Reframing Aging Style sheet to change the language: “Say older people or older adults” based on research that these terms are perceived as “more capable than seniors.”  More substantively, unveiling this rebranding seemed to reinforce Old Lives Matter, during this COVID-19 pandemic.  Particularly in residential LTC facilities, fixation on older adults at risk has “othered” them as passive, dependent and vulnerable in a medical model that decided they should not be allowed to take certain risks like embracing life via social visits with precautionary measures in place, while allowing psychosocial risk of extended isolation to jeopardize their well-being and “will to live.”  It has been unsettling to learn about former clients/residents "deaths of despair” while being protected from COVID-19 risk. 

Blame Industrial Revolution’s compulsory mass education for age grading, and using age to organize the tripartite division of life course into schooling, work and retirement. I also resisted this age-segregated institutionalized life course, in favor of age-integration by mixing schooling, employment and retirement with all ages—especially older adults with stories to share. Now COVID-19 pandemic has blurred these boundaries with homeschooling, remote work, and leisure at home… with less age-segregation, perhaps another silver lining in this pandemic?

According to Pew Research, multigenerational households are back, mostly out of necessity:  A majority of young adults in the U.S. live with their parents for the first time since the Great Depression. Intergenerational connections can help reduce ageism, and maybe return to family as informal support for LTC?

Nowhere to go, and all booked up

Attended Gerontological Society of America’s Age-Friendly University Special Interest Group Zoom meeting to get ideas as I develop curriculum to integrate aging content in MSW curriculum that engages students and promote more age-inclusiveness. Cool to see a couple of scholars (Rona Karasik, Nancy Kusmaul) who are included in my literature review on importance of student interaction with older adults, based on theories of social learning and intergroup contact to challenge ageism. To adapt to remote learning, contact includes exposure to older adults’ stories in films and books. 

10th annual Legacy Film Festival on Aging scheduled this month did not take place, so I streamed several films listed in Professor Karasik’s article, Two Thumbs Up: Using Popular Films in Introductory Aging Courses; only a handful appeared deserving of thumbs up; and such a dearth of older women! My eyes really needed a break from the screen, so I turned to finding literature about older adults with emphasis on intergenerational relationships. When did I last read fiction as I have been so occupied listening to non-fiction experiences of clients/older adults and reading gerontology literature?

When asked “what do you want to be when you grow up?” I considered working in a library or publishing (but ultimately decided on careers that involved travel), so going to indulge here with books…

Reunited with Mills alum to join President Elizabeth Hillman (RBG doll on bookcase!), faculty (Elder in Residence Patricia St. Onge and Natalee Kehaulani Bauer, who are Natives) and students for discussion of Tommy Orange’s There There: A Novel (2018), a multigenerational story of Native Americans in Oakland. Native Peoples who relocated from reservations to urbanized ancestral lands found no there there—just a concrete place, like Gertrude Stein returning to her childhood home to find rural Oakland gone.  Older women (Opal cares for three great-nephews, Maxine is guardian) use the power of storytelling as antidotes to generational trauma (self-medicating to hide/forget with substance abuse and violence as legacy of colonial racism and genocide), offering hope/healing through multidimensional stories of resistance and renaissance (Alcatraz Island occupation) in contradiction to stereotypes…source of greater authenticity in searching for heritage and identity than googling “what does it mean to be a real Indian.” And the idea of home as spiritual community is powerful.

Mills College put up for sale works by dead white men: Shakespeare’s First Folio (1623) sold for nearly $10 million, and handwritten score by Mozart (1770s).  Persimmon Tree, a quarterly magazine by women over age 60 and published in association with Mills College, paid tribute to RBG in its latest issue. 

Litquake co-founder Jane Ganahl (also writes about solo aging) hosted discussion with Amy Tan (Boomer) and Kevin Kwan (Gen X), who both wrote books made into films about filial piety in Chinese families, The Joy Luck Club (1989, 1993) and Crazy Rich Asians (2013, 2018).

During her Zoom appearance, Amy moved her head away from screen several times, so got peek at her craftsman house in Sausalito, with views of SF Bay and Angel Island.  After contracting Lyme disease over 20 years ago, Amy and her hubby made plans to build an all-accessible two-bedroom house to age in place, with elevator, roll-in showers, walk-in bathtubs, wide sliding doors, etc. designed to be functional and beautiful using African mahogany and Asian aesthetic. 

Where the Past Begins: The Life and Work of Amy Tan documentary for PBS was in progress by filmmaker James Redford, who died at age 58 from liver cancer this month. 

Rachel Khong moderated Good Things in Small Packages: Writing Short Stories at Litquake.  She wrote short stories, magazine article about her Po-Po (grandmother) who had Alzheimer’s, and then her first novel, Goodbye, Vitamin (2017), about a millennial who returns home to help care for her father, a retired history professor diagnosed with Alzheimer’s. Probably should check out this novel before its film starring Constance Wu of Crazy Rich Asians.

Senior Planet’s Ryan Kawamoto hosted Ruth O. Saxton (ROS) Presents: Stories That Defy Expectations of Old Women.  Ryan introduced ROS as his classmate’s mother and Mills English Professor Emerita, recently retired after 46 years.  This spring she taught her final course with 15 Mills students and 30 Oakland Senior Center participants who were hungry for conversation beyond bingo and ballroom dancing activities.

Her latest, The Book of Old Ladies: Celebrating Women of a Certain Age in Fiction (2020), was a 20+ year project, begun at age 60 and interrupted by traumatic brain injury from a 2004 car accident.  To gather “examples of good aging,” ROS asked for recommendations, googled, hired students to look for stories, reviewed 100 stories before whittling to 31 stories organized in 5 chapters (Romancing the Past, Sex After Sixty, Altered Realities, It’s Never Too Late, and Defying Expectations).  After printing 800 copies, book sales going well so her book is being reprinted. (UK blogger Caroline Lodge maintains Older Women in Fiction Series.) 

ROS resisted “deathbed bookends,” or stories of a fictional older woman at her deathbed pining for unrequited romance of her youth, and challenged other stories of being a wife and mother as incompatible with career, citing her privileged position as white academic at an all-women’s college. (During this pandemic, women working in academia have struggled with demands of work and caregiving, with reduced productivity that could jeopardize their ability to get tenure—further exacerbating the gender gap where women represent 40% of tenured faculty…but perhaps this pattern is less so in an all-women’s college? ROS' daughter Kirsten T. Saxton, Mills '90, is also Mills Professor of English. Mills faculty can enroll children up to age 10 at Mills College Children's School on-campus.  In general, record numbers of women have dropped out of the workforce during pandemic, which has implications for their retirement security.) 

To combat ageism, ROS recommended: don’t let anyone tell you what you can’t do because you’re a certain age; have friends of all ages including your own cohort age; instead of young people limiting conversations with older people to nostalgia (“what was it like when you were little?”) talk about the present as well. 

SFSU Creative Writing Professor Carolina De Robertis (Mills MFA ’07) hosted super engaging chat with her former student, Jose Antonio Vargas (SFSU BA, Political Science, ’04),  about his memoir, Dear America: Notes of an Undocumented Citizen (2018).  Jose’s grandparents made it possible for him to immigrate from Philippines to California, in pursuit of the American Dream.  At age 12, Jose separated from his mother in the Philippines to live with his grandparents in California after his Lolo (grandfather in Tagalog v. Hawaiian word for idiot) paid $4,500 to a smuggler.  However, after Jose came out gay as a teenager, Catholic Lolo rejected him viewing homosexuality as a sin and complicating plan for Jose to marry an American woman to gain citizenship (before gay marriages became legal).  

As Jose turned to school as his “second home,” he benefited from mentors like his high school principal and superintendent who connected him to a network (“underground railroad”) that financed his SFSU education, living expenses, driving lessons and obtaining a driver’s license so he could pursue journalism. Jose explained that if freedom for undocumented persons like himself doesn’t come from government reform, then it must come from the people you trust: “Surround yourself with people who will say yes to you, who will open windows when all those doors are being closed.  Your survival and your strength comes from that.”

Jose decided to become a journalist because if he was not supposed to be in USA because he didn’t have the right kind of papers, he would write his existence into America by publishing his name (byline) on paper! But this risky endeavor concerned Lolo, who expected Jose to work in unassuming low-paying jobs that undocumented people often take.  Instead, Jose shared a Pulitzer Prize with other writers at The Washington Post.

At age 30, Jose came out as undocumented in his “Outlaw” (2011) essay published in The New York Times, followed by Documented: A Film by an Undocumented American (2013).  Jose faced age discrimination, being “too old” for adoption as a teenager and being “measly one year” over age 30 limit to qualify for DREAM (Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors) Act. 

“No human being is illegal.”—Elie Wiesel 

Though Jose thought “life did not start until 40,” he started writing his memoir at age 36 because he was tired of lying (not talking about his mom in Philippines, except with his grandparents), “passing” (replacing his native Tagalog with PBS manner of speech), and hiding (affecting his own mental health).  Jose used his handwriting on book cover, re-writing narrative of being undocumented=not citizen.  He also called out hypocrisy: undocumented farmworkers who are essential workers, but not essential humans?

http://sitn.hms.harvard.edu/flash/2020/racial-disparities-in-covid-19/

Public Service Announcement: Black, Indigenous, and People of Color (BIPOC) have been dying disproportionately from COVID-19, including many immigrants making up the majority of essential workers who more likely interface with others and sometimes without adequate protections (like employers who fail to provide PPE to workers who care for sick/frail people).  Support Essential Worker Bill of Rights! 

Jose also directed White People (2015), interviewing white millennials for MTV documentary...would be great to see follow-up on Old White People! Or undocumented older people who are also “lying, passing, hiding” with no place to age? So important to hear oral histories of diverse older people to counter white-washed history. (Happy 51st anniversary, Ethnic Studies!) When I worked in ALF, residents decided to “cancel” Thanksgiving after empathizing with painful history of genocide from watching Great Courses Plus series on Native Peoples of North America.  If more people can act likewise to cancel Thanksgiving gatherings, no worries about spreading coronavirus! 

Carolina also shared The Purpose of Power: How We Come Together When We Fall Apart (Oct. 2020), memoir and activist book by Alicia Schwartz Garza (SFSU MA Ethnic Studies ’17), co-founder of Black Lives Matter movement and organizer with National Domestic Workers Alliance.   

Institute of Noetic Sciences (IONS) hosted Shifting Ageism: How Consciousness Affects Our Experience of Aging. 

According to the history of ageism, older adults as knowledge keepers (storytellers) for the community began to lose their status when the printing press was introduced in 1440.  Yet, living older adults retain value with their oral histories (memories)—particularly if invited to dialogue.  Being genuinely curious enough to listen to older people about their lives and ideas have led to ideas about my own future, what really matters in life, adapting to and surviving challenges, etc.—how to become a more understanding person?

“Local” privilege

Attended Weaving Voices: Looking to Our Past for New Political Visions, which asked, “What kind of leadership do we need to take us out of COVID-19?” This Zoom meeting featured recorded oral histories of political leaders “to revisit the era of economic change from plantations to tourism, and political change with the return of AJAs and rise of the Democratic Party in the 1950s…sparking huge transformation.”  Following statehood, Hawaii Lt. Governors were Native Hawaiian-Chinese: James Kealoha (Republican 1959-1962), William Shaw Richardson (Democrat 1962-1966).

Included in the otherwise all-male lineup of politicians was Helene Hale (1918-2013), who represented Big Island of Hawaii, retiring at age 88 after suffering a stroke. 

Because my parents are aging in place in Hawaii, I pay attention to COVID-related news that might impact them.  I decided to postpone visiting them, especially frightful to learn how COVID passengers allowed to fly and/or die on flight. Hawaii government’s COVID response has been so frighteningly chaotic during its latest surge that U.S. Surgeon General Jerome Adams was dispatched to provide federal support for COVID-19 testing and contact tracing (after purge of incompetent state health and public safety officials placed on paid leave), and then Hawaii police arrested Adams for taking pictures in a public park! 

Anyway, this political visions program based on oral histories of long-dead politicians could have benefited from voices of living kupuna, preferably Native Hawaiian (like University of Hawaii Professor Emeritus Haunani-Kay Trask), “talk story” based on memories of this transition when Hawaii went from Republican (haole, Chinese) to Democrat (Japanese, Filipino) rule, political party identification stratified along race/ethnicity and social class; Hawaii stuck in Democratic Party groupthink (giving meaning to Ezra Klein’s claim that opposite of polarization is suppression, not consensus).  Sounds like Hawaii needs another transformation to get out of COVID!

“If the Republican Party gave us sugar, the Democrats gave us Waikiki.  If the Republican Party gave us racism, the Democrats gave us another form of racism.”—Haunani-Kay Trask, Centennial of the Overthrow (Jan. 17, 1993)

Two non-kupuna, non-Native, non-local panelists (one female, one male so at least there was some gender diversity!) alluded to current leadership challenges like lack of accountability in Democratic Party (“incumbency protection racket”), lack of transparency in Governor’s suspension of Sunshine laws that closed off public meetings/records during pandemic, less economic diversity from working class representatives like earlier politicians who grew up in plantations to be “more responsive to social welfare issues”, etc.

“Today, modern Hawai’i, like its colonial parent the United States, is a settler society. Our Native people and territories have been overrun by non-Natives, including Asians. Calling themselves “local,” the children of Asian settlers greatly outnumber us.  They claim Hawai’i as their own, denying indigenous history, their long collaboration in our continued dispossession, and the benefits therefrom.”—Haunani-Kay Trask, Settlers of Color and ‘Immigrant” Hegemony: “Locals” in Hawai’i (2000) 

What I found noteworthy in program (but not highlighted by panelists, even after my question about plantation "no make waves" culture stifling progress was read during Q&A) was recording of State Senator John Ushijima (1959-1982) discuss how attending college in the mainland gave “locals” a different perspective from the prevailing “plantation mentality” and motivated them to seek change for “mobility.” Note current Hawaii Governor: “local” who never lived outside Hawaii for any substantial time to gain a different perspective, so he maintains status quo, like denying Medicaid to Micronesians and approving retroactive pay raises for unionized state workers despite growing budget deficit during pandemic.

“When I think back on all the crap I learned in high school

It’s a wonder I can think at all…

Everything looks worse in black and white…”

--Paul Simon, Kodachrome (1973)  

These are mere observations as I have no family history connected to plantations in Hawaii, which gave rise to “local” culture like mixed plate and Pidgin English, synthesizing disparate ethnic contributions to reinforce polarization of insider (“locals”) v. outsider (haoles, recent immigrants) and marginalization of Native Hawaiians seeking sovereignty.  Interracial people seem to identify with group based on appearance, like Barack Obama identifies as Black, though he was raised by haole mother and maternal grandparents. 

Generational trauma seems to keep Hawaii as provincial small-town: “Locals” size up people based on “eh, where you wen’ grad (high school),” fluency in Pidgin/Hawaiian Creole English (resistance against Standard English representing haole oppression), ethnicity, and tanned complexion.  Forget racial paradise myth: “locals” (as in Asian settlers, rather than Native) take care of their own tribe in plantation tradition of “divide and control,” rampant patronage, ethnic groups pitted against another (ethnicity-based pay differential, segregated housing), resulting in shabby treatment to Native Hawaiians and most recent immigrants – painfully apparent with Micronesians during this syndemic. Leave it to “locals”/their allies to praise their replication of racial capitalism/plantation village built on a floodplain for formerly homeless families that provide source of cheap labor (exploitation) to benefit nearby laundry business owned by former First Lady.  Is this indicative of leadership that will take “us” out of COVID-19? 

COVID-19 corner

Woo-hoo! Last week, SF became the 1st Bay Area county and 1st major city in California to rise to least-restrictive/minimal yellow tier for reopening during this COVID-19 pandemic.  Wonder how much being stuck at home to avoid smoke from wildfires helped?!

According to SF Department of Public Health (DPH) COVID-19 data tracker based on 681,211 test results reported to date: 12,399 positive cases and 148 deaths (64% male; 58% age 81+, 16% age 71-80, 14% age 61-70, or 88% of deaths age 60+; 38% Asian, 25% Latinx, 22% White, 6% Black; 1% homeless).  Total COVID-19 deaths: over 229K in U.S., over 1 million worldwide. 

SF has averaged 5,000 tests per day (exceeding goal of 1,800) and positive coronavirus test rate of 0.89.  Of the 20 most populous U.S. cities, SF has the lowest positivity rate and the lowest COVID-19 death rate. 

Yesterday, SF decided to pause further reopening next week due to uptick in SF’s key health indicators over last two weeks, COVID-19 cases (rise from 3 daily cases per 100,000 residents to 4 per 100,000, or 25% rise, signaling orange=moderate alert) and hospitalizations (rise from 23 to 37 patients, signaling red=high alert).  Data-driven SF DPH Director Grant Colfax reported other rises in COVID-19 cases, statewide and nationwide: 38% in California, 41% in U.S.; and since we don’t yet grasp the magnitude and potential duration of these increases, pause will help mitigate virus, adding “I wouldn’t be me unless I reminded you” to keep wearing masks, physically distance, wash your hands, avoid large groups, etc.    

According to CDC, self-reported engagement in COVID-19 mitigation behaviors (mask wearing, handwashing, physical distancing, crowd and restaurant avoidance, and cancellation of social activities) was highest among age 60+ (Boomers +) and lowest among age 18–29 group during April to June.  Whereas mask wearing increased over time, other reported mitigation behaviors decreased or remained unchanged. 

SF allows "shared spaces" for outdoor dining on sidewalks, so diners are unmasked while drinking booze and talking loudly—spewing respiratory droplets and aerosols further on passersby, practically forcing me to road facing traffic.  Unacceptable during this pandemic, so I called 311 to complain that outdoor dining should be in parklets, and my complaint was referred to SF DPH. Back in April, I emailed suggestion to SF COVID-19 Economic Recovery Task Force to adopt plexiglass partitions on dining tables as done in Hong Kong, which never shutdown dining during pandemic. 

While COVID-19 cases have increased, COVID-19 deaths appear flat mostly due to treatments learned six months after pandemic (that certainly benefited President Trump’s recovery from COVID-19).  In KZYX Coronavirus Update, Dr. Drew Colfax explained that physicians now know aggressive treatments for low oxygen level like use of ventilators may have been counterproductive; keep lungs dry instead of giving fluids that fill up lungs of COVID patients; rotate entire body regularly in prone position to increase oxygen; dexamethasone and remdesivir. This is reassuring news, unless one ends up with long-haul COVID, while we wait for vaccine/herd immunity. 

While adapting to New Normal, I miss hearing Dr. Drew Colfax’s earlier rants about how this COVID-19 pandemic was entirely preventable if there had been stronger national leadership.  This continues to be the case so worth repeating and ranting! It is unconscionable for government to fund corporate welfare, like $21 billion “no strings attached” COVID-19 relief to nursing homes (of which 70% are for-profit), without expectation to invest in resident care and safety of direct care staff.  Need to demand better because accountability and transparency is critical to take us out of COVID, restore public trust, and ensure survival of storytellers!